| Author: Larry Wallberg | Date: 2010-02-27 |
Email: |
Home page |
| Poor Des. You're gonna make your brain explode if you keep reading the drivel coming from the Catholic News Agency. And even the comments, too? Oy.
|
|
| Author: marc | Date: 2010-02-27 |
Email: marc@desertscope.com |
Home page |
| I know. I'm a glutton for punishment. As a recovering Catholic (truth is, I even wore a cross until about 2003), I feel like most Jews. While I have yet to meet a Jew who is also a believer, I sympathize with those atheists who consider themselves cultural Jews. So I pop in once in a while on various Catholic websites.
As the saying goes, you can take the girl out of the trailer park, but you can't take the trailer park out of the girl. |
|
| Author: Larry Wallberg | Date: 2010-02-28 |
Email: |
Home page |
| It's interesting that you bring up the term "cultural Jew," because I've been growing less and less comfortable about referring to myself that way. Yes, genetically I'm an Eastern European Semite, and my ancestors practiced Judaism. I have a lot in common with some other people who were raised in a Jewish-influenced household. But, as I've gotten older, I've grown to think that "Jew" is a uniquely religious term, not a national or ethnic one -- except when used by bigots. What I am, culturally, is a "New Yawker." I have far more in common with other people who grew up in my hometown (particularly those who were raised in the Bronx), regardless of their ethnicity, than I do with, say, Southern Jews. I would never just say "no," if someone asked me "Are you Jewish?" But I'd wind up giving them an explanation and a qualification that would probably bore them shitless.
As a corollary: I don't think one can be a cultural Catholic. Italian Catholics, for example, are very different from Polish Catholics, who are, in turn, a world apart from Irish Catholics. So where's the part of the "Catholic culture" that isn't firmly rooted in religious practices? You may not be able to take the trailer park out of the girl, but you can certainly watch her outgrow her childish superstititions. |
|
| Author: marc | Date: 2010-03-02 |
Email: |
Home page |
| In Richard Feynman's writings, he might speak of "that's between you and your Rabbi," where a Baptist would say "Parson," (or something like that) and I would say "Priest."
But even as I type this, it seems a little more nonsensical |
|
Records 1 to 4 of 4